“What If?”: When Fear Leaves No Room for Desire
Dernière mise à jour : 15 oct.
On living through hypotheticals, trying to meet expectations, and finding space to listen to what we feel.

Luisa left home every day at seven in the morning, carrying a backpack on her shoulders and the weight of anguish along with it. She walked to the bus stop, moving through life as if between commas: home, university, work, home. Throughout those hours, questions occupied her mind. Why couldn’t she become interested in anyone? Why did her relationships seem to require so much effort? Why, even when she was with someone, did she feel a loneliness she could not explain?
To those who knew her, there seemed to be no reason for any of this. She was beautiful, intelligent, articulate. She attracted attention, received invitations, had friends. But the reasons others imagined she should be doing well could not reach what she was actually living through. Luisa was never alone, yet it had been a long time since she had experienced the feeling of truly being with someone. It was as though she hovered wherever she went, present only in body.
A Question That Had Not Yet Been Asked
One day, while walking through the university, she ran into Bel. An acquaintance whose presence made her want to stay. Around Bel, conversation seemed to require less effort. Luisa noticed herself becoming interested, attentive, slightly more present. They sat down for coffee. In between one subject and another, Luisa spoke about the sadness she felt in her relationships. She had already tried being with different men, but none of them awakened in her that desire to remain close. Her friends would ask what was missing. She asked herself the same question, without finding an answer that convinced her.
Bel listened and asked her a question: “And what are you interested in?”
It seemed simple. But Luisa realized she had spent a long time trying to understand why she did not desire what was expected of her, without asking herself what actually sparked her interest. Almost speechless, she asked for the bill and went to work. The question went with her.
When an Answer Brings New Fears
On the way, Luisa began to recognize something she had not previously been able to admit. She wanted to stay close to Bel. There was something in Bel’s presence that awakened an interest she had never found in the relationships she had tried to build. But recognizing this brought another voice with it: Bel was a woman. What would happen if she allowed herself to live that feeling?
What if her friends pulled away? What if her parents did not accept it? What if she disappointed the people she loved? What if she lost her home? The questions were no longer only about what she felt. They began to anticipate everything she might lose if she made room for that feeling. Some fears are grounded in real risks. Family rejection, financial dependence, and violence may be part of the experience of those who move away from expectations about how they are supposed to love. Listening to a desire also requires taking into account the conditions in which a person lives and the resources available to protect themselves. For Luisa, however, every possible loss seemed to demand the same response: preventing that feeling from existing within her at all.
Living Through Hypotheticals
“What if?” can be a way of thinking before acting. It allows us to consider consequences, recognize limits, and make careful choices. But it can also take up so much space that it no longer helps us decide. One question leads to another. When we think we have found an answer, a new condition emerges that must first be resolved. Little by little, life becomes suspended while we wait for a certainty that never arrives.
Luisa was trying to find an explanation that would make her feelings acceptable to everyone. As though she first needed to justify them before she could acknowledge them to herself. This demand can appear at different moments in life. When choosing a profession, ending a relationship, wanting to leave a place, or discovering a way of loving we had never imagined. We feel something, but first we try to determine whether we are allowed to feel it. Meanwhile, we continue going through the motions of everyday life. We show up, respond to people, do what needs to be done. But an important part of our experience is given no space.
What Anguish Can Lead Us to Ask
As a psychoanalyst, I am interested in the conflict that appears when someone feels they must distance themselves from an experience in order to preserve the place they occupy in relation to others. This may involve family expectations, learned values, and images of who we believe we should be. Often, these references are so deeply internalized that we can no longer distinguish what we want from what we believe we are supposed to want. Bel’s question opened a small distance within that certainty. By asking Luisa what interested her, she gave her the possibility of listening to herself differently.
A question does not resolve a conflict on its own. But it can change the point from which we begin to think about it. Luisa no longer had to investigate only what was wrong with her relationships. She could begin to recognize what happened within her when she was close to someone she desired. Her interest in Bel was not something that needed to be corrected. The suffering lay in the conflict between being able to recognize that feeling and fearing the consequences of giving it a place.
One Encounter Does Not Solve Everything, but It Can Change Something
In Luisa’s story, there came a moment when she sought Bel out. They kissed. They laughed. And Luisa experienced a sense of presence she had been missing for a long time.
The world had not changed completely. The reactions she feared could still happen, and there would be choices, conversations, and difficulties ahead. But something of that experience no longer needed to exist only as a hypothesis. There was a difference between imagining what she might feel and allowing herself to discover it.
This moment does not need to be understood as a magical solution, nor as a path everyone should follow. Every story has its own timing. Recognizing a desire does not oblige anyone to act on it immediately, make it public, or arrive at a definitive definition of themselves. It can begin in a more discreet way: admitting that something is happening, finding someone to talk to, no longer treating one’s own feelings as an accusation.
Finding Space for Yourself
In analysis, these questions can be given space without the person having to arrive with a ready-made answer. It is possible to speak about a desire and also about the fear it awakens. To investigate what is at stake in a choice, what one fears losing, and which expectations have been guiding one’s life. This work can help distinguish necessary caution from a prohibition that no longer leaves room to exist. It can also allow someone to build resources for facing difficult situations while respecting their own timing and circumstances.
Perhaps Luisa’s first movement happened before the kiss, in that café, when someone asked her what interested her. A small question, but one that included her in the life she was trying to understand. When the “what ifs” take over everything, it can become difficult to notice what we feel in the present. Finding a space to listen to these questions can also be a way of participating in one’s own life again.
If fear, other people’s expectations, or doubts about what you want have been limiting your choices, this can be explored in analysis. I work with adults in Portuguese, English, and French, in Paris and online. To request an appointment, please get in touch.



Commentaires